SEO Content Brief: “Do I Need to Be My Dog’s Boss?”
Welcome to one of the biggest bug bears of modern dog training, the question of “Do I need to be my dog’s boss?”
The really short answer to this is no, you don’t. It’s based on some seriously outdated methodology that science has rejected for over 30 years.
Honestly, I think most dog trainers of merit are probably sick to death of hearing the “boss” malarkey – but I want to put some time in and actually discuss it. So, if you’re ready? Let’s dive in.
training is really important, but where’s the tipping point?
What Do We Mean By Being Their “Boss” in Dog Training?
This is usually wherein the trouble lies. Because the intention of “Show them who’s boss” is founded and rooted in dominance theory. Usually, it refers to a highly punishment based method of dog training. Usually, this comment or instruction will commend you for taking physical action with your dog or denying them lots of things.
Honestly, you know the types of instruction this leads to. It’s the “Don’t let them through the door first”, “Eat first”, “humping your leg is a sign they don’t respect you”, “bite them on the ear” and 101 other myths brought to you by the alpha bro dog trainers (such as Ceasar Milan). Usually all in stride of trying to convince you they don’t hurt or that your dog needs to respect you.
And, really, I think part of this is that the concept of being a “boss” was stuck in the 90’s version of being a boss, where you were a hard ass, and everyone bowed down.
However, because there are no standard terms and the industry is loaded with jargon that’s not beginner friendly, you may have come to the conclusion that being a “boss” to your dog means something other than this… and ultimately, your way may be okay, but it’s a word I (as a professional dog trainer) would encourage you to find a different way of expressing, if you can.
What is it we’re really seeing here? An alpha dog? Nope, it’s likely a small dog who’s had their space invaded and isn’t confident.
The Myth of the Alpha Dog
Picture this: a wild pack of wolves, roaming through a dense forest, led by a single, domineering alpha who maintains order with an iron paw.
This image of the alpha dog has not only captured our imaginations but has also influenced how countless pet owners interact with their dogs for decades. The concept of the alpha dog was born out of early wolf pack studies, where researchers observed captive wolves and concluded that the pack dynamics were all about dominance and submission. It was believed that dogs, as descendants of wolves, required the same strict hierarchy to maintain order.
But let’s hit the pause button on that narrative for a second.
Modern research has rolled over that old-school thinking, revealing that those early studies were not jut a little wrong, but drastically wrong as they were studied on captive wolves who were taken from their homes and forced together creating a disgruntled, stressful environment, and reflecting nothing of their natural way.
As it turns out, the dynamic seen in captive wolves isn’t reflective of that in wild wolf packs or domestic dog families. Instead of dictatorship, wild wolves tend to live in family units that work together more cooperatively than competitively. The so-called ‘alpha wolf’ is less of a tyrannical overlord and more of just a parent doing their best to lead the family.
big dogs quickly get the “alpha” BS pushed on them, which is largely unfair.
So where does this leave our house wolves? Well, the insistence on being the unchallenged “boss” of your dog, based on a misinterpreted wolf hierarchy, can lead to a strained and anxious relationship (and indeed is theorised by many trainers to be contributing to the increase in behavioral issues in the domestic dog).
When we approach our dogs under the alpha pretense, we might lean on forceful methods to assert our supposed dominance. This can confuse our four-legged friends, lead to fear, and harm the trust that forms the foundation of a healthy owner-dog bond.
The key takeaway? Your dog doesn’t need a boss; what they need is a guide. Just as with humans, leadership in the dog world works best when it’s garnished with kindness, consistency, and clear communication. So, instead of trying to establish dominance over your pooch, consider focusing on positive training methods that build a harmonious rapport, where you can both flourish in each other’s company without misconceptions about being the alpha.
What Actually Matters in Dog Training
Now, this is where the line blurs, because truthfully, leadership and being a good boss are desirable qualities in dog training, but being a bad boss doesn’t, and neither does what being your dog’s boss used to be about.
What is important though is;
- Boundaries. Using management to set your dog or puppy up for success from the very start is really important, and the key component for teaching your dog “right from wrong”
- Understanding. learning our dog as an individual, observing how they communicate and understanding that they don’t want or need to control us, and simply are trying to lead a peaceful coexistence with us is really clutch also.
- Rewarding. We don’t work for free, and our dogs shouldn’t either. Reward them well for listening, and over time? You’ll build a dog that loves to listen to you.
- Teach appropriately. This is more than just what you teach, it’s also how you teach. Don’t expect your dog to jump from addition to quadratic equations. Make it simple, make it enjoyable, and prioritse what needs to be taught. I’d always rather see a dog that can walk nicely on a leash than a dog who knows how to balance a cookie on their nose.
This is usually referred to as positive reinforcement training. Where compassion, understanding and knowledge are prioritised over domineering control.
It’s simple, but it’s essentially the same as what makes a good relationship with another human, ironically. And yes, you could argue this is good leadership or what a great boss will do. But, commonly in the dog training industry and world, that’s not what being a boss refers to.
It will commonly be the relic referred to as dominance theory.
The departure from dominance theory and the idea that you need to master or control your dog has been something we, the dog training industry, have been trying to overcome for a really long time now.
Do we need to be firm in dog training? We need structure, but we don’t need any sort of punishment
Practical Tips to Be The Best Dog Guardian (Without Being a “Boss”)
Stepping up as a responsible and loving dog guardian doesn’t mean you need to impose a tough “boss” persona. In fact, let’s stash away that notion in the doghouse, shall we? Becoming the best buddy for your four-legged friend involves warmth, understanding, and yes, a good stash of treats. Here’s how you can ensure tails are always wagging in your household:
1 – Engage in Interactive Play
One of the joys of dog ownership is the playtime you share. Fetch, tug-of-war, or a simple game of hide-and-seek can provide mental and physical exercise for your pup. Not only does it strengthen your bond, but it also allows your dog to understand that you are a source of fun in their life, not fear.
2 – Embrace Positive Training
Positive reinforcement training is where the good stuff’s at—literally. It’s all about rewarding behaviors you want to see again. This could be as simple as offering a treat, praise, or a belly rub when your dog follows a command or exhibits good behavior.
Examples of Daily Opportunities for Positive Reinforcement:
- 1 – When your dog walks naturally beside you: When your furry friend walks nicely on a leash without pulling, offer them a small treat or a cheerful “Good dog!”.
- 2 – When your dog chooses to nap or relax: When your dog or puppy takes them off for a nap? Perfect time to give a calm, “Good puppy”. This way, you’re encouraging
- 3 – When your dog acts appropriately with company: Such as choosing to sit when you’re talking to company!
Cultivate Patience and Consistency
Think of yourself as a patient teacher rather than a demanding boss. Mistakes are part of the learning process, and scolding only sours your relationship. Instead, consistently reward the positive and gently redirect the negative. Dogs are creatures of habit and respond well to routine and reliable actions.
[IMG width="500px" alt="Operant Conditioning Indie the german shepherd and...